The truth about Trulia and Zillow!

Copy of the email Trulia sent me.  Thank you Trulia...but this listing closed almost 6 years ago!!!

Copy of the email Trulia sent me.  Thank you Trulia...but this listing closed almost 6 years ago!!!

Trulia and Zillow are not accurate sources for Staten Island Real Estate.  I recently received this email from Trulia (see above).  It basically states that they have linked one of my listings to my Trulia account.  Good job Trulia.  Except for the fact that my office sold this listing almost 7 years ago!

Trulia and Zillow are filled with misinformation, incorrect photos, sold or expired listings still being advertised as for sale, even advertising homes for sale….that were never on the market!  It’s a disservice to clients who may already have to deal with a potentially frustrating real estate transaction.  

Agents continually need to explain why Trulia and Zillow post such inaccurate information.  Both Trulia and Zillow allow any agent, for a fee, to have their name and photo appear prominently beside homes listed for sale in a given region, even if they aren’t the agent who represents the seller!  In reality, the agent in the photo may know little about the property or the neighborhood where the house is located, further frustrating consumer’s efforts to get accurate answers.

All of this further denigrates all real estate professionals and the housing market as a whole. is reasonably accurate because it is linked to our local MLS, although it sometimes has some lag time between changing property statuses and price changes.  The best source for Staten Island Real Estate is a direct IDX (Internet Data EXchange) site such as or www.Herman.NYC both of which have real time, up to the minute prices, property updates, and status reports.  Real time information is a necessary tool for today’s Staten Island home buyer or seller.

Approximately 98% of all real estate transactions start online.  Don’t you think consumers should be able to get accurate information?



Advertise on Trulia

Get more leads

Submit listings

Herman Herrerra –

We have automatically linked 1 listing(s) to your Trulia account. Please ensure that the listing information below is accurate to take full advantage of the 17.3 million active buyers searching for homes on Trulia each month. If any information is inaccurate, click the “Edit” link next to the listing to update the information on Trulia.

304 Travis Ave —  Edit the information for this listing
Price: 439,900.00
Number of photos: 4
Next Open House Time:

QUICK TIP: Create an ad containing your listings to be shown every time home buyers search in your area with Trulia Local Ads.

Best Regards,
The Trulia Team